spillthemilkvintage_storefront spillthemilkvintage_store


spillthemilkvintage_america dressor

be bold


Spill the Milk Vintage aims to inspire people to seek their unique individual style with boldness and Do It Vintage! New or Vintage, almost every item can be re-purposed, re-designed with endless multi-tasking possibilities. This is the heart of each item in the store.

It’s easy to transform a simple room by adding a “conversation” starter piece to make a statement about you. Our friendly staff is knowledgeable and helpful in answering your questions about scale, color and style. Think of it as a complimentary design consultation.

Our Showroom receives new treasures daily so check the website frequently for pictures or stop in the store to see what’s new.

The best part of a resale vintage store is that you are sure to find a one of a kind treasure or an item that brings back a fond memory.

Spill the Milk prides it’s self on having an eclectic selection that includes, furniture, mirrors, armories, benches, cabinets, and chairs. Collectable signage, original and pre-owned artwork mixed in with funky urban salvage and décor. We also sell vintage clothing, purses, small gifts and jewelry to cherish and share. Along with too many other items to mention and new ones on the way.


If you see an item on our site you’d like to purchase, please call our store at 219-286-3955 during business hours. Purchased items must be picked up within 2 business days. Excluding Sunday and Monday-Closed. If the buyer does not pick up items in agreed time, the items will be returned to the showroom floor for resale.
Delivery service is available in the Valparaiso and surrounding area. Estimate upon request.


**Our building has a carport so don’t let the weather stop you! See you soon!


spillthemilkvintage_store anglejpg


What’s Behind Our Name – History of Spill the Milk Canvas


IIn the Spring of 1948, Al Steele Sr. was working as a machinist at McGill Manufacturing in Valparaiso, Indiana. Earlier that , Al asked for a leave of absence to travel with a carnival in Wisconsin during May through September. Mr. McGill agreed to the absence, and keeping his word Al returned to his position later that year.

With his job secure, Al purchased a ton and a half 1939 Chevrolet truck. He also secured credit for needed lumber and hardware from the Foster Lumber Company for two concessions. One concession was “Spill the Milk”. It was a Knock Down game in which three baseballs were thrown at five stacked leaded milk bottles. The other game was “Pop the Balloon” a dart game. His wife Maytha ran the dart game with nine year-old daughter Mary Ann who blew-up the balloons. Eleven year-old son Al Jr. was the barker for the cork shooting gallery owned by his grandfather, L.E. Steele, who also operated a penny arcade and pony ride on the early Wisconsin route.

The day after Hayes Leonard School let out for the Summer, the family headed north to their first spot – Clintonville, Wisconsin, joining Bowdart Shows. Bowdart Shows were based out of Shawno, Wisconsin.

An important note is that in the late 1940’s almost every town in Wisconsin had a baseball team. Even a small town of 500 had a ball team. When the carnival came to town the ball players would line up to play “Spill the Milk”. On many occasions, the ball players still in their uniforms from the Saturday night town game came to throw balls at the milk bottles.

It quickly became apparent that these ball players, especially the pitchers, threw the balls very hard. When they missed the bottles, the balls tore thorough the canvas on the back of 16 x 16 concession tent.

Al quickly realized he needed a heavy duty canvas back stop. This would take some time to acquire, so in the mean time he placed a 4 x 8 foot panel of 3/4 plywood behind each table of targeted stacked milk bottles.

L.E. Steele had purchased his penny arcade tent from Mr. Bernie Meddelson who owned O’Henry Tent Awning Co. on Clark St in Chicago, Il. Al Sr.asked Bernie to paint a themed “Spill the Milk” back stop for his knock down bottle game. The O’Henry Tent Co. had a reputation for quality products. This is attested to by the fact that this canvas is over 60 years old, has been hit hard by thousands of baseballs, traveled thousands of miles, torn down, rolled up, stored in a barn and is still in the great condition you see today.

The painter at the O’Henry Tent Co. during that time was Fred O. Johnson. Mr. Johnson was from Chicago and worked at O’Henry Tent Co. from 1934 – 1974. The awning company provided show banners to many carnivals and circuses such as Ringling Brothers Barnum & Bailey. Fred is now known as the Picasso of carnival, side show and circus canvas. His works of art have been auctioned at Sotheby’s in New York.

Steele’s Amusements, the name Al Sr., used for his concession business grew into a traveling carnival consisting of twenty- four rides, forty plus concessions, and numerous side shows. For 28 years, the show winter-quartered on the same property from where the family first traveled to Wisconsin the Summer of 1948. The show played it’s last season of celebrations and county fairs in Indiana, Illinois, and Wisconsin in 1976.

Al Sr. was my grandfather. I was one of seventeen Steele’s that traveled with the carnival. Each year in late Spring, grandmothers, grandfather, brothers and sisters, aunts and uncles, husbands and wives, nephews and grandchildren left Valparaiso for twenty weeks each Summer to work on Steele’s Amusements Midway.